Monday, February 20, 2012

Jail and the mentally ill

Bridget O'Shea's article on yesterday's NY Times Health page featured Sheriff Tom Dart and others, complaining about Cook County Jail being the biggest mental health provider in Illinois. I never quite know what to say to people who seem to think this is so pathetic.

The presumption of course, is that individuals who are sick belong in hospitals, not jails. But there's a highly ironic and eery similarity between mental "hospitals" and jails. The people of Illinois should notice, just for example, that these hospitals have locked doors and guards to make sure the "patients" don't escape.

I would love to walk around the cell blocks at 26th and California with Tom Dart, and say, "OK Sheriff, point out one guy here who's mentally ill as opposed to just a bad guy, and explain to me how you yourself can tell." My guess is, he'd only be able to reliably distinguish between the regular criminals and the mentally ill in his own jail by looking at a file or a record, or asking somebody else who had looked in a file or record, which might include pronouncements by psychiatrists or other so-called mental health professionals.

These pronouncements are called diagnoses. But the people who make them are completely confused these days about whether and in what sense they are valid at all. There's is never any objective test, and DSM-5 intends to define mental illness of every kind on an unbroken continuum with normal behavior. In other words, nobody knows exactly where to draw a line between the guys who are sick and the guys who are bad at Cook County Jail.

For ten years, I've worked with "patients" in this system who were found not guilty of violent crimes by reason of insanity. I'm down at 26th & Cal almost every week. Some of my clients have been basket cases who didn't brush their teeth or bathe; others have been smart, totally symptom-free, unmedicated murderers. Sometimes their doctors have insisted that they had to take psychotropic drugs, or even threatened to get court orders to force them; other times the clinical team has carefully contrived to change a diagnosis so a non-drug treatment plan could be justified to a true-believing judge.

The one thing that's always obvious is, it's not medicine or science in any sense that the public could ever recognize. It's a tortured attempt at a giant social control machine which can run on automatic without any responsibility by any individual human being, so nobody ever has to be punished, or blamed, or wrong. People can just get their brains fine-tuned by the experts, and we can all live happily ever after.

This is the probably most destructive social delusion in history. Maybe it's easy for Sheriff Dart to pretend he's being humane and scientific and medical, when he moans about too few state nuthouses to relieve his crowded prison. The truth is he's just passing the buck like all the other helpless, wasted bureaucrats we pay.

And ultimately, the New York Times reporter has no excuse not to know that. Nor do any of the rest us.

Thursday, February 9, 2012

LEGAL POSITION AND SUGGESTED ARGUMENTS: POSSIBLE GENERAL IMPLICATIONS FOR STATE FORENSIC MENTAL HEALTH INSTITUTIONS

(Summarized upon request of a state hospital treatment team and patient "Mr. X", and offered as an earnestly recommended, though admittedly radical strategy: February, 2012, by the patient's attorney.)

Situation

Mr. X was found "Not Guilty by Reason of Insanity" for murder over thirty years ago. He is diagnosed on Axis I with schizophrenia. He’s in his mid-sixties now, and has had no symptoms of psychosis for many years, despite not taking any psychotropic medication. The court has granted increased privileges gradually, but very likely remains impressed by a supposed bottom-line necessity for psychotropic medication if this type of patient is to be granted a conditional release. The treatment team wonders what to do next.

Relevant considerations

1. Viewpoint of the court.

The court has only one valid purpose consisting of two elements: See that Mr. X is treated humanely, and keep him secure to ensure the ultimate safety of the community.

Mr. X was not culpable for the murder he committed because he was insane. The court, as society’s agent, is not supposed to have any interest in punishing him. However Mr. X's treatment is not entirely for his own benefit. In fact, it’s much more for society’s safety as far as the court is concerned, and this is the first element of the court’s only valid purpose. Iatrogenic neurological disability would actually be justified, even if it were grossly dehumanizing (think of the old fashioned ice pick lobotomy), on this basis alone.

However, the second element is the social imperative to be humane. Society places very high negative value on cruelty, so it becomes the court’s job to minimize or eliminate cruelty. Society believes, and the court is utterly committed to the idea, that scientific medicine is one of the best solutions man has devised to increase human comfort and happiness with less perpetration of cruelty among competing individuals in a severe world.

Therefore, the court remanded Mr. X to the custody of the state’s experts in mental health, a scientific medical specialty, to miraculously improve his personality and behavior by fine-tuning his brain chemistry until he becomes an upstanding citizen and society is secure.

Although the court is essentially aware that the state’s experts in mental health are not really miracle workers to this degree, it rather desperately wishes they were. And it may bitterly resent any reminders that the experts fall short of such an ideal, because the court, like the society which it serves, is afraid of being fooled or cheated.

Judge Z should not be interested in the treatment team’s uncertainties. He theoretically wants only their relatively confident synopses of empirical knowledge, applied to the case and question at bar. However, the court and (even more so) the State’s Attorney, will welcome almost any artifice to argue or justify a decision for keeping a murder defendant locked up. Thus, any uncertainties of the clinical team (or the court's “independent” experts) might be seized upon to serve that purpose more readily than if they favor release.

There is a standard described as “reasonable medical certainty” - but all that really means is any confident opinion voiced by a doctor. Opposing and equally reasonable “medical certainties” are presented to the court all the time, and those win which just sound a little bit more confident and understandable to the judge who’s there that day. The court knows very well that expert testimony is only “objective truth” in some small, nominal way. It’s mostly persuasion, and that is not any problem, but part and parcel of our system of law.

2. Viewpoint of the clinical team.

The team consists of public employees who have varying levels of medical and non-medical expertise. As a team, they are expected to restore the mental health of a patient to a point where he or she will not be a danger or severe burden to the community, before the patient will “Theim out” (be released pursuant to a U.S. Supreme Court precedent regardless of treatment success or failure).

There is a presumption that poor mental health was in fact what caused the patient to be dangerous, before the team ever laid eyes on him. The team is not really allowed to dispute that issue, but is paid by the state to work within the presumption.

For at least a couple generations now, mental illness has been conceived to be a proper medical problem. This is basically because there was once great optimism that it must be caused by brain disease, which could with improving scientific research, etc., be identified and ultimately cured. In any event, nobody yet claims any ability to cure mental illness: it just gets treated, with the goal being a limited, temporary, or at least more modest improvement than a true, simple and permanent cure.

The only thing relevant to mental illness or the lack of it, which the team can objectively observe or test, is the patient’s behavior. (This includes what the patient says, or writes, as well as how he acts.) No clinician, no matter how good they are or what tools they have, can know with any certainty what the patient thinks, or how he feels: such conclusions are entirely derived from observed behavior.

Applied medical technology, e.g., psychotropic meds, may have observable and predictable correlations with behavioral changes. However, nobody is sure how or why that works. These days, people pretty high up the food chain of cutting-edge psychiatric research are admitting (just for example) that the “chemical imbalance” theory of mental illness was always an urban legend, and any competent psychiatrist should have always known that.

So treatment does not equal medication. Treatment is rather whatever can, without a lot of ugliness, produce a stable, positive change in the bad guy’s behavior. This is where the team’s real expertise lies. For all practical purposes, the public pays the forensic mental health treatment team not for expertise about the mind or neurology or philosophy. They pay them to be experts at mercifully changing very bad behavior.

Treatment must be collaborative. Involuntary “treatment” is never more than a desperate emergency measure. Dr. Y doesn’t prescribe medication unless Mr. X agrees to take it, as long as Mr. X is not beating up everybody in the room daily. Although he killed somebody, and society will not let him walk out of the state hospital now, the only valid treatment for Mr. X must have his un-coerced stamp of approval. It just doesn’t qualify as treatment otherwise. This is an element of the team’s empirical, clinical expertise. It is part of why they are a team, not just Dr. Y alone, dictating medical details without need or allowance for questions, perspectives or other help than his own. It’s part of why we have mental institutions and a professional specialty of forensic psychiatry, not just police forces, prisons and pharmacies.

The treatment team’s professional pride is in delicate collaboration and caused stable behavioral change among people who can only be feared and loathed by the lay public. This is a relatively heroic activity.

3. Viewpoint of Mr. X’s attorney.

I couldn’t care less whether Mr. X has schizophrenia, epizootiphrenia, drapetomania, or any other specific, defined “mental illness”. He killed somebody and he’s not being punished for that, but everybody wants to be sure he’ll behave himself in the future. It’s an extremely dicey speculation, and I never would have become involved with it at all, except that this state has unfortunately made it a very bad part of the law (my profession), which needs cleaning up!

It seems to me that convincing Judge Z, the Department and the treatment team to arrange the conditional release of a schizophrenic killer who is not taking psychotropic meds will help. For one thing, it will remind everyone of the practical responsibility to change a bad guy’s behavior, as opposed to just pretending they can fix his brain whether he likes it or not.

As a society, we have gotten too damn complex and glib about evil. We call Dr. Y-the-wizard-with-a-magic-pill to “cure” killers, instead of personally standing on the bridge and telling the X-monster, you shall not pass! We have a death penalty in our state, but no capital case juror will ever be required to flip the switch personally. When the law is a machine and a Rube Goldberg menagerie of impersonal processes, it insults me. And it makes me feel terribly insecure, like nobody’s really there.

I think Mr. X has been successfully treated and cured of schizophrenia, or he has outgrown it, or he has learned not to act crazy, whichever works. The Department, the state hospital, Dr. Y and the treatment team deserve full credit for this result. Mr. X’s behavior has been exemplary and stable for a long time. The fact that he has been so symptom-free without medication for an extended period actually makes the prospect of his continued recovery in the community even better.

In any event, beyond a certain point in time there is no further clinical treatment purpose for keeping Mr. X at a state hospital, running up the taxpayers' $450/day tab! The chance that Mr. X will hurt anyone because of mental illness is slim already, and it can never be reduced to absolute zero. We could keep him psychiatrically confined for many more years, and we would be no more certain about this than we already are, unless we just keep him until he dies.

Mr. X should be conditionally released to a situation where he will be closely monitored for five years, and where regular reports will be sent to the court, random drug screens done, etc. He should not be required or even encouraged to take psychotropic medications, while he has no symptoms of psychosis. Given that Mr. X is healthy and in his sixties, I think he would be crazy to start taking meds now. It would be more likely to destabilize him than serve any hypothetical “prophylactic” purpose.

Suggested handling

1. Start putting a packet for conditional release together now, and file it with the court as soon as possible. The violent crime and schizophrenia dx, with no psychotropic meds, will certainly be a sticking point at all levels. Work through this problem, which exists almost exclusively in institutional culture, not in empirical medicine. Do not merely fudge the paperwork to make it look like a new evaluation just happens to change the Axis I. There are plenty of published, empirical psychiatric research studies to justify an expert opinion that Mr. X’s dx does not have to be wrong to explain the observed fact that he’s fine now. Locate and read the professional research, and get comfortable with that perfectly valid opinion.

2. Send a straightforward, confident recommendation to the court stating that Mr. X is suitable for conditional release; and that the risks of treatment with psychotropic medication would outweigh any possible (e.g., prophylactic) benefits in his case, hence they should not be prescribed. State this as the expert opinion of the Department treatment team, held with a reasonable degree of medical certainty.

3. When the court's independent evaluation comes back in total disagreement (which it will), litigate the issue aggressively. Judge Z will almost certainly go with the opinion of the court's independent evaluator, rather than the Department opinion. So what? Use the opportunity to move the court’s opinion in our direction as much as possible. Enter every possible study into evidence, showing that people perhaps do spontaneously recover from schizophrenia without meds, that nobody really knows the brain basis of schizophrenia and there may not be one, that schizophrenia may not even be properly described as a unitary “disease”, etc. Enter every study showing the dangerous side effects and complex downside of psychotropic meds. Recruit outside expert witness testimony to back these points up.

4. When Judge Z denies the petition for conditional release (which he will), file another one as soon as the statute permits, and litigate the whole thing all over again, but better.

5. Repeat this procedure until a conditional release is granted without any recommendation for psychotropic medication, despite an Axis I schizophrenia dx.

6. Keep in close touch with Mr. X after he is conditionally released and don’t let him screw up.

Monday, December 5, 2011

The Therapeutic/Protective Service State: Guerrilla Actions

Individuals who refuse psychiatry when their betters think they should accept it are quite likely to suffer wrathful coercion from what Tom Szasz calls the Therapeutic State.

Families and groups who are cynical about the proclaimed beneficence of the Protective Services State (e.g., "Child Protective Services" or "Department of Children and Family Services") may also be regarded essentially as though they are mentally ill. They will be presumed to not know what is best for their own children, and they will be asked to prove negatives which are impossible ("How can we know for sure that this won't happen again?").

Children misbehave, sometimes badly. Parents are not supposed to punish them anymore, they're supposed to turn them over to experts outside the family who are employed by the state. It's very similar to (and sometimes it directly and explicitly involves) forensic psychiatry.

So if your 13-year-old child rebels against a type-1 diabetes diagnosis, runs away from home, gets pregnant and learns how to selectively manipulate you and the CPS bureaucrats back and forth against each other depending on whom she wants to defy on any given day, well guess what? You're quickly going to feel very much like somebody who is involuntarily committed in a state nuthouse.

The key to understanding the similarity is the concept of institutional machines meant to do things that individual people shouldn't have to do or don't want to do. Forensic psychiatry and child protective services are attempts at dependable, impartial, no-fault, objective processes to relieve real people from having to pay attention. The experts running the machines supposedly know how people -- as cogs in other machines -- ought to work. It's all nonsense, of course. The real world results are consistently and embarrassingly terrible. And anyone who knows himself or herself to be more than just a cog in somebody else's machine instinctively hates both forensic psychiatry and child protective services, or at least they do when these institutions are aimed "incorrectly" (at them).

But by the time people find out that forensic psychiatry and child protective services alike are all about state tyranny, not about state therapy or state protection or helping anyone, well, it's too late, you "can't fight city hall." You have to collaborate (which means surrender) or the machine crushes you, and everyone -- even your family -- will say it's your fault!

Back in 1964 a young man named Mario Savio gave a beautiful speech in Berkeley, about making the machine stop. It was a clarion call for civil disobedience and guerrilla actions.

Now, a half-century after the Berkeley Free Speech Movement, we confront forensic psychiatry and child protective services, and we lose over and over again. How can we put our bodies upon the gears and upon the wheels and upon the levers, and upon all the apparatus, and make it stop?

The following three tactics or principles are suggested, as the most basic guerrilla strategy.

Tactic/principle #1. Don't participate, even tacitly. Don't acknowledge that anyone is trying to help you, if it doesn't feel like help to you. Don't let anyone say you agreed to something, if you don't think you actually did agree, freely. Never let anyone call something your duty or your job, if you never actually accepted it as such, yourself.

If your psychiatrist can't confirm that you have a "chemical imbalance" by way a blood test or a brain scan (which of course, they cannot do), don't accept his explanation about why the meds are therapeutic. If they get a court order for involuntary medication, make them hold you down to inject the drug into your body, never let them pretend it's not forced.

Never acknowledge the social worker's expertise or the guardian ad litem's authority over your child. Never fail to challenge their motives, which are egocentric, elitist, ignorant and mercenary. Never believe these people are acting in anyone's best interests but their own.

Just don't ever cave or agree, at least not in your heart. The little tyrants are trained and drilled to trick you into thinking that you have agreed when you haven't, that something was your idea when it wasn't, that something is best for you when it's their own arbitrary, pet theory. You might pretend, just to gain somebody's confidence or a tactical advantage. But don't ever forget what you know yourself.

Tactic/principle #2. Make it an expensive, time consuming nuisance. The reason the state makes machines and automatic, uniform processes is that people think they can't afford to deal with live individuals. So, be a very live individual. When somebody mentions a policy, make them show it to you in writing, then make them tell you its purpose. If answers don't make sense, keep asking, don't let it drop. Be that child who asks "Why?" to every answer, endlessly until all the parent has left is, "Because I say so!" The state pretends to rationality, not force, so it is more vulnerable than a parent, it has to keep explaining.

A friend told me years ago that the law is reasons (small r, plural). Whoever has more of them and is willing to stand up and say them longer than the other guy, wins. The reasons don't have to be all that good, either. They just have to be good enough that nobody is sure you don't believe them yourself. If you have more reasons, more questions, if you're staying longer and talking more than the little tyrant wants to, you'll win. You have to wear them down, be the squeakiest wheel they've ever heard.

The state appears to have all the money, but the little tyrants are often answerable for their efficiency or lack of it. If it's generally expected that one hearing will result in the efficient disposition of a case, the bureaucrat who can't finish it in three hearings can look pretty bad to his or her boss. When a member of a mental health treatment team has to have legal representation for a deposition and that has to go into his boss's budget, well, maybe the machine will figure out it's easier not to petition for involuntary treatment, or not to place a child in a foster home, after all.

Always ask for a change of venue, always ask for a different judge, but always have more reasons than anyone thinks you could possibly need. Always make them late for dinner.

And by the way, when it comes to this factor of expense, if you can easily pay thousands for a lawyer, it can help you a lot. But many lawyers (especially the ones whom the court appoints for you for free) really believe in the system you're fighting against. You can still use them, they are ethically required to follow your instructions and your strategy if they are representing you. But be aware that you may be spending (or paying for) lots of hours arguing with your own attorney. I hate to say it, but sometimes it might be better to study the law and represent yourself.

Tactic/principle #3. Always look for the good in each individual, even while you never miss an opponent's lie or illogical, arbitrary claim. Ultimately you can separate well-intended individuals from the state machines which they think they have to slavishly serve. Expect this to happen.

You are in the right, and a good person will know that. Get them to betray the empire, remove them from the matrix. Love your enemy.

If you are more persistent than they predict you could ever be, if you are a very creative nuisance, and if you look for the good in individuals and presume they will ultimately come around to your side, you'll be surprised how often you'll get defectors.

And you might end up a hero.

Wednesday, August 31, 2011

How do you "develop" alcohol abuse?

Today's Chicago Tribune headlines its Health & Family section with an article about teen drinking. The federal Centers for Disease Control did a survey which supposedly "indicates that youths who start drinking before age 15 are five times more likely to develop alcohol dependence or abuse later in life."

I know it's politically correct to believe in alcoholism as a disease. Mental illness is also, of course, a disease or a bunch of diseases. One "develops" such diseases just like cancer or the measles.

That's how we're supposed to think, otherwise we might tend to blame somebody instead of curing them. God forbid any one of us should ever impose any idiosyncratic morality on anyone else, or judge anyone on any standard which is not explicitly and expertly medical....

And of course, modern medicine could eventually cure every human problem if we mere mortals will just pay enough taxes, and subordinate our inferior lay judgment for those superior understandings of the proclaimed experts about what's best for us.

On the other hand, maybe not.

Another article, this one in the Chicago SunTimes on the same day, features psychologist E. Scott Geller of Virginia Tech's Center for Applied Behavioral Systems. Geller's research doesn't seem to show that kids just inadvertantly catch the disease of drinking too much. His conclusion is more like, well, they get drunk on purpose because they like it.

Education toward "alcohol awareness" has proven useless in efforts over thirty years. When researchers took breathalyzers to college parties and bars to show students their blood alcohol content, it actually encouraged them to drink more.

What a surprise. But perhaps only to those who delude themselves with this fantasy of medical cures for any and all socially problematic or disagreeable behavior.

The rest of us know stupid and bad when we see it, not to mention free and responsible. We resort to time-honored moral constraints like blame, shame and regret, which actually work better than psychiatry.

Friday, August 26, 2011

Will psychiatry die without psychosis risk?

The sudden demise of "Psychosis Risk" as a DSM-5 diagnosis may foretell the doom of psychiatry as we know it.

History tells us that empires occasionally crumble overnight. My favorite example is the Aztecs. In 1519 the wealth and power of Tenochtitlan was literally beyond European imagining. Only two years later Hernan Cortez had not just taken Montezuma's throne, he had wiped out the Aztec religion and obliterated their whole society.

And who would doubt that things change faster today than they did in the sixteenth century?

Robert Whitacher loses hope against the wealth and power he sees lined up with the forces of the psychiatric empire. I've heard similar pessimism from no less than Thomas Szasz.

But that power is spread very thin. Subject peoples are bitter and impatient, and our modern sun god - science - is no longer easily placated.

Sometime back in 1950's America the idea arose: We've got some really bad people who do terrible things, but with modern medicine and the atomic bomb and so on, maybe instead of just punishing them we can fix their brains! Then we'll all be good people, no more bad people.

Everybody believed in modern medicine and feared the atomic bomb, so biopsychiatry was an easy sell.

But half a century later, nothing has happened. We have no improved definition of schizophrenia, let alone an objective diagnostic test or cure. The latest drugs are still no better than simple exercise, or a placebo. It requires the idiosyncratic charisma of a snake charmer like Patrick McGorry to inspire government budgets for mental health, and the twisted talent of an old adman like D.J. Jaffe to propagandize the crowds into "seeing" the emperor's new clothes.

In the last decade or two, basic genetic and biological research has made it more and more obvious that there will never be a simple cure for any "mental illness" - partly because we don't even know what we're talking about when we use that term. The disease model applies no better here than it does to poverty, or war. We are not improving human behavior medically. The naive, 50's-America optimism was evidently a delusion for psychiatry and its true believers.

But true believers must defend the faith, no matter how desperately. Enter "psychosis risk" and "prodromes" calling for "early intervention".

My friends at CCHR and elsewhere think these ideas are marketing schemes contrived by pharmaceutical companies. I rather see them as desperate, last-ditch, hail-Mary rationalizations for a doomed paradigm.

I can imagine old guys like Nate Kline and Freddy Goodwin (and let's add Bennie Rush into the mix, too) on the golf course or sitting around a coffee table with Pat McGorry, wondering what the hell's wrong. "It's too complicated, after fifty years and all the money we ever wanted, there's still no cure?!?! We can't just fail, guys. We can't let Pasteur and Salk be the last heros. Maybe if we start treating kids real early, these drugs will do something. Maybe the disease gets smart enough to hide, or fool us, unless we go after it when it's just getting started, even before anything's wrong... Let's just test 'em all and treat 'em, then we'll finally figure it out, and we'll finally create our super... uh, better... man."

But oops! Paddy (he's Irish, rght?) McGorry flat-out abandoned the plan just the other day. His renunciation of "psychosis risk" for DSM-5 purposes presents the sudden possibility that biopsychiatry is really coming to the end of its road. Not even Allen Frances, who has taken the early interventionists to task more than any other establishment figure, really seems to appreciate this.

These guys are all still dragging human sacrifices up the mountain. But the empire may be gone forever.

Saturday, June 11, 2011

An utterly wonderful turn of phrase!

I LOVE this:

"He gets symptomatic over rights."

I heard it from a social worker at Elgin Mental Health Center the other day, I'll call her Cindie. A patient for whom Cindie was responsible had been complaining that several dvd's had been confiscated from him for no good reason. The patient is a straight-A, on-line college student. The confiscated dvd's were relevant to an anthropology class he was enrolled in. He even had a letter from his professor saying so.

But the bossman of the clinical unit, a nurse's aide named Alfonso, had to prove to this patient that college success counted for nothing. The staff at a state nuthouse can take away anything they want to take away, any time they want to. Patients are bugs to be squashed at Alfonso's whim!

Cindie supports this kind of squashing in the bughouse, because it's really the only way she can obtain respect for her profession and activities. Patients who go to college tend to avoid therapy groups, because they find out that their classes are infinitely more valuable than the basket weaving and navel gazing Cindie teaches. When one of these (upstart!) college kids gets out of the nuthouse, Cindie and her therapy groups might get less credit for it.

Alfonso just steps on bugs directly, and laughs. I actually have been amused in a sick sort of way, by his unflinching cruelty.

Cindie, being much weaker, has to say, "He gets symptomatic over rights."

That is just wonderfully pathetic.

Tuesday, May 31, 2011

English and Inquisitorial law

The Chicago Sun-Times editorializes today on a proposal to encourage questions from jurors in civil trials. Unfortunately, the article perpetuates a critical misunderstanding of our system of law.

The purpose of trials under our English system is not entirely to get at the truth, at least not by any human means. We presume, with humility perhaps tragically lacking under the alternative Napoleonic system, that ultimate Truth may remain beyond mortal ken. When our conflicts go to court, we do what we're actually capable of doing as imperfect beings: we fight it out. Trials are adversarial rituals intended to ensure that even where there must be a winner and a loser, as few bystanders as possible should be hurt by the process of decision.

Carefully limiting violent conflict is a far more practical human purpose than establishing any Secure Reign of Exalted Truth. From the Inquisition, to the black gate and hot mushroom cloud of 1945, we have history's lessons against arrogance. Incidentally, jury service is often a brilliant exercise in this precise social reality!

So, in a much darker way, is any work which gets a person up-close-and-personal with state psychiatry. Mental health systems function on an inquisitorial model. The "doctor" (psychiatrist) knows The Truth - whether a person's chosen behavior is a symptom of disease, what label a person deserves, and what should be done about bad behavior (e.g., forced drugging). Courts abdicate their traditional role of decision in favor of this Medical Truth. A disparaging remark maliciously scrawled in a chart by a medicalized prison guard ("Security Therapy Aide") becomes a scientific fact in court!

Psychiatry degrades both medicine and the law. Psychiatry kills civilized humanity.