Sunday, June 29, 2025
Joe Pierre, Michael Gadson, and Milt Pinsky
Saturday, June 28, 2025
Joe Pierre's egghead SOB arrogance
Maybe I should take it as a compliment that Dr. Joe Pierre, the San Fransisco psychiatrist with whom I occasionally argue/discuss on social media, believes that I am so educated as to know the meaning of "QED" as an abbreviation for the latin phrase, quid erat demonstrandum. This translates to "that which was to be proved." It's a sort of showboating or peacocking at the end of a written or logical argument, perhaps analogous to a raised fist and screaming grimace after a long three-pointer right at the buzzer in basketball, or a gloating, ecstatic dance in the end zone after a touchdown reception.
Dr. Joe has been increasingly prone (like a huge number of people, maybe most of the population of the USA these days) to political tirades presented as obvious logic that everybody just has to agree with or prove themselves to be of subhuman intelligence. The famous example of this, and of how it can utterly fail to win over opponents, was Hillary Clinton's phrase, "basket of deplorables." (It's pretty safe to presume that Dr. Joe voted for Hillary, by the way, and if he reads this article, I expect his reaction will be, "Of course I did!")
Recently, Dr. Joe posted on X: Measles update: 1168 cases and counting--we're now 106 shy of the 1274 from 2019, which would make it the worst outbreak in over 30 years. With new airport exposures, it's likely we'll get there. Meanwhile, RFK Jr is like "vaccines are the problem."
I responded to his post: You're rooting for this, right Doc? Like it's more important to score political points against anyone who challenges orthodoxy than to identify and disseminate truth.
His retort was: Don't conflate "expecting" with "rooting." The effects of RFK's vaccine denialism will demonstrate themselves soon enough and will likely be well beyond the scope of measles. Highlighting this is a case of QED, not "wanting Trump and his regime to fail" as is often claimed.
I could go on and on about this exchange.
- If he weren't "rooting," Joe could easily have added "unfortunately" or "alarmingly" somewhere in the post. And rather than "...we'll get there," he could have written, "...I'm afraid it will happen." His "expecting" rather than "rooting" denial is transparently disingenuous; sorry, but he was rooting. I should add that rooting for a disease, while simultaneously claiming that the same disease is so dangerous as to justify abrogating people's informed consent and coercing them to accept medicine they don't want, seems quite contrary to the fundamental ethics of medicine.
- What exactly is "RFK's vaccine denialism?" That's a curious way of labeling it, probably meant to imply without having to argue that RFK's views on vaccines are ignorant prejudice and simply must give way to the proper judgment of experts or the established facts, like with "Holocaust denialism" or "climate denialism" or some other clearly discredited denialism. But many people consider some issues to still be open, and they have a freedom of speech right to keep talking about them. If Joe doesn't want to take any responsibility for convincing anyone of any arguable point on vaccines, he would be free to simply laugh at the dinosaurs for their views. But then why would he bother to go on about it on social media?
- I never said anything about wanting Trump to fail. Joe's protest there is a protest too much. He definitely wants Trump to fail more than he wants the measles outbreak to be limited to any particular number. Saying "Trump and his regime" also might betray Joe's view that the current administration is some non-democratic entity rather than the duly elected, appointed and confirmed executive branch of our government. Isn't this a brand of "denialism"?
Sunday, June 1, 2025
"Patients" with no doctors at fake "hospitals"
Saturday, May 31, 2025
On diagnosis being bullshit
Friday, May 30, 2025
Stahl's Deprescriber's Guide--seriously?
One fascinating story from the American Psychiatric Association's annual meeting this month in Los Angeles is the mere fact that such a stalwart psychopharmacology authority as Stephan M. Stahl may be jumping on a bandwagon, which until very recently was widely derided as "antipsychiatry." Stahl must be one of the top ten promoters of psychiatric drugs in the world! Why would he help "deprescribe"-?
Maybe it's an opportunistic business move for Stahl. His new book is due out in exactly six months, and it's expensive ($60 for a paperback of just over 500 pages). I may buy a couple dozen copies and give them out to clients and nuthouse psychiatrists. Any legitimacy attributed to getting people off psychiatric drugs is deliciously seditious in the context of the state plantation system. But I can't help thinking my friend Rodney Yoder will be absolutely sure that the real intention here is to own the deprescribing craze, i.e., own it to exploit it, or to make it disappear.
If we take everybody off the drugs, we will inevitably saddle the forensic psychiatric system with the impossible requirement that clinicians must talk to patients. They hate that. They want to be doctors who are obeyed, not counselors who must listen or empathize. And anyway, it's too expensive (not to mention useless) to do anything with dangerous crazy people other than just drug them into sufficient disability so that they conveniently, without ugliness, disappear. That is clearly the modus operandi of Illinois' Department of Human Services.
In the meantime, I saw headlines this morning about North Carolina's psychiatric slave system, which sounds to me very similar to Illinois' plantations. It can be expected that horrible abuses will be found in every state if competent investigations are conducted. They might be. We are inches away from a widespread realization by the American public that the kind of "mental health" we have been sold since 1945 has been a harmful scam. Psychiatry as we have known it will cease to exist without forced "hospitalization" and "treatment." Tom Szasz predicted that long ago.
Involuntary psychiatry has long been lamented, at least on and off, as necessary. But it doesn't protect the public or serve justice. The drugs have long been lamented, at least occasionally, as imperfect. But they don't help anyone or cure anything.
These facts are being acknowledged, implicitly, even in the media and amazingly, at APAAM2025! There will be efforts to distract attention from the facts, but psychiatry may lose its status and power.
That would be a happy development indeed. Psychiatria delenda est!
Friday, May 23, 2025
Talking the British out of their illusions...
Wednesday, May 7, 2025
The Packard psychiatric slave plantation
One of the most valuable rights involuntary "patients" have, enshrined in Illinois' Mental Health and Developmental Disabilities Code [405 ILCS 5/1-100 et seq.], is the right to unimpeded, private and uncensored communication with anyone they choose. Section 2-103 of the Code presents a few, slightly elaborate qualifications or exceptions to this right, but the intent of the law is more clear from the careful, precise language of the qualifications or exceptions themselves.
For example, the law makes the Director of any particular plantation (e.g., Sara Broyles at Packard) personally responsible for ensuring that this right is respected, and personally accountable to issue written rules and written explanations of any restrictions of this right.
In other words, it is very clear that the law does not intend for individual clinicians on the units to spontaneously make up rules about phone use or restrict "patients" from using the phones in any arbitrary way when they just feel like talking to any friends or family, for any reason. This is important, by the way. Section 2-103 appears in the chapter of the Code which is entitled, "Rights of Recipients of Mental Health and Developmental Disabilities Services." (Emphasis added.) It's a matter of rights, not merely an administrative detail. They have to let patients talk on the phone as freely as possible, and they have to organize and document doing so.
Well, there's this social worker on Lincoln South Unit named Michael Fitz who seems to believe he can gratuitously violate the intent and letter of this law, for his own purposes of (perhaps) proving that he can punish and harass a "patient" whom he doesn't like on any particular day or who causes a mere nuisance once in a while. Fitz may also need to prove he's smarter than the "patient", or failing that (since he definitely isn't smarter), prove that he can overwhelm that "patient" and treat her or own her as a slave. Packard is a plantation, after all. Fitz is an overseer, he's absolutely not any helping professional.
Yesterday at about 2:00 PM, Fitz's "patient" got a phone call from a friend she had not spoken to in a long time, who may not have even known she was "hospitalized" (I am heavy on the sarcastic quotation marks for this article) in Illinois. She spoke with her friend for about half an hour, and hung up. The friend called her back to continue the conversation after about twelve minutes. But Michael Fitz, who evidently had been meticulously clocking the phone time of this "patient", quickly interrupted to say in a hostile or impatient, arrogant tone, "You've been on the phone for an hour and forty-five minutes, and you have to hang up!" The "patient" complied, and Fitz went back into the office or nurses' station from which he had been surveilling the phone use with an eagle eye, and wrote up a report.
Later, the evening shift staff on Lincoln South (who only must be presumed to have read Fitz's report) unnecessarily and unpleasantly admonished the "patient" that she had to "follow the rules and not spend so much time on the phone."
But what rules? As best we know there is no written restriction signed by Sara Broyles saying that no "patient" may spend more than some stated amount of time on the phone. The rule (Section 2-103) is unimpeded, private and uncensored communication with anyone. Not to mention, if Fitz actually wrote that the "patient" had been on the phone for an hour and forty-five minutes, that was a false report possibly amounting to perjury; and there was no one else waiting or asking to use the phone at any time while Fitz's "patient" and been on it. Fitz was just being a petty tyrant, acting arbitrarily out of spite. But of course, this is normal on the plantations. The slaves must be kept under control and dominated by any means.
Section 2-103 also mentions attorneys, and apparently gives them special importance as far as "patients'" communication access goes. (See, 405 ILCS 5/2-103(d).) A recent experience with the same "patient" and her social worker Fitz (among other overseers of slaves at Packard) illustrates how the spirit of the law, often, is frustrated by the plantation's desperate obsession to control the slaves.
Several Defendants in a federal case I have recently filed consider that they should remain as the Plaintiff's clinical team, and that they need not have their attorneys present in a treatment plan review meeting which I attend as an advocate for that "patient". This seems rather dicey to me, but I know several of the plantations are severely understaffed to the point that they are technically unable to provide mental health and developmental disabilities treatment as required by law. (I wrote about this in some detail recently.) So, maybe Packard is as severely understaffed as Choate, and their calculation here is, it's better for Defendants in a civil suit to take the chance that they may inadvertently provide evidence for civil claims, than to end up being criminally culpable.
The "solution" to this quandry, as best I can decipher, is to carefully clarify, or get me to admit, that I am only the "patient's" advocate when I attend a treatment plan review (TPR), and I am not acting as the Plaintiff's attorney for those minutes while the Defendants in the case are present without counsel. I went along with this the other day, even though I'm not sure I understand or anyone can predict all the implications.
For practical purposes, of course it's all nonsense: first and foremost because the "treatment" the "clinical team" is supposedly "planning" in a TPR is itself pure nonsense, when they pretend to be curing a non-existent brain disease with their horribly damaging "medicine" but cannot even bring themselves to efficiently diagnose a condition as obvious and medically treatable as pregnancy, and they implicitly admit all that in an opposition attorney's presence, without their own state-provided counsel; secondly, in the particular case, these Defendants will settle or not according to the specific facts discovered, not according to shades of definition unless they want a jury trial with lots of media.
As I've written before, pregnancy is a stubbornly objective fact, especially when it's carried to term; and a child is an expensive responsibility that somebody will certainly have to pay for.
So prevent communication, severely control phone use, and maybe words will count more than deeds.
Right, Fitz? Right, Gadson?
