Thursday, June 13, 2024
Psychedelic Renaissance or a new drug dark age? (Ruminations)
Thursday, June 6, 2024
More on sex with mental patients
Wednesday, June 5, 2024
FDA panel says NO to medical ecstasy!
Yesterday the Psychopharmacologic Committee of the U.S.Food & Drug Administration voted 9-2 to decisively reject purported effectiveness of MDMA "treatment" for PTSD, and 10-1 to overwhelmingly find that any benefits of such "treatment" are outweighed by the risks.
I put quotation marks around "treatment" because the committee's findings highlight the embarrassing fact that the people pushing this whole thing never did figure out what MDMA-assisted psychotherapy, or any other psychedelic-assisted psychotherapy, actually is to begin with.
Some like to believe it's the pill that actually cures PTSD. The drugs are catalysts to scramble a brain/mind in such a way as may effectively force a new and better point of view in a patient, who realizes that his/her past trauma is unimportant in light of the vast existential connectedness experienced while tripping, which would surely save the world if only enough people could turn on, tune in, and drop out.
Oddly perhaps, the only apparent theory behind electroshock treatment is similar: a patient gets hit with force violent and painful enough to make him/her look differently at less impressive things.
But recall (if you're old enough) the dramatic appearance of three huge letters on a hillside in Berkeley, California where high school classes had traditionally painted the name of their school or class year. As 1967 opened, the only message on that hill was: "L... S... D". Psychedelics were mystical messianism from the beginning, never scientific medicine. Flowers and amazing music came with the drugs, so the whole thing had an aesthetic appeal which ECT severely lacked.
And these days, bureaucrats at government agencies are prone to think the drugs do little or nothing by themselves without some talk therapy (although they can't say what kind) or psychological work. The preparation before tripping, and the integration sessions afterward, are essential. Without the psychotherapy element it's not safe or effective.
The FDA monitors and regulates food and drugs, not psychotherapy. They also had to notice certain implications of data (and omissions of data) from the trials cited in the presentation to their committee yesterday. These might make them very happy that they don't regulate psychotherapy. Boundary violations are a larger problem when patients are so suggestible on drugs like MDMA.
But the truth is it has been more than a generation since psychiatrists even tried to be any good at talking therapy. If they're going to get back into it now because the "decade of the brain" was bullshit and all the antipsychotic and antidepressant drugs failed to solve the problems of humanity, they'll have to start almost from scratch. Handling the patient who's freaking out on LSD or confronting demonic entities on psilocybin is more or less the opposite of starting from scratch!
These guys don't even know not to evaluate patients' conclusions and thoughts for them (they think that's what they're supposed to do as the experts!), and they don't even realize that acknowledgement is a critical part of two-way communication. They're just as likely to kill productive therapeutic realizations with veiled criticism or skepticism, as to enable them by appropriately professional manners.
So at best they end up controlling people, not helping them. Psychedelic drugs certainly assist with (vicious, covert) control, basically by wiping out people's self control.
The MAPS/Lykos/Doblin crowd will hate yesterday's FDA hearing result, and they'll moan sadly about the urgent need to advance new and better therapies for the terrible problem of PTSD. I on the other hand will hope that yesterday was the first sign of the complete demise of the celebrated "psychedelic renaissance"!
These guys want money and control; they have no clue how to help, and psychedelic drugs will never be better therapy.
Saturday, June 1, 2024
Sex with mental patients
Sex is a fundamental expression of humanity. In fact, it's a fundamental expression of being alive in a broader context than just humanity. Animals, and even plants, have sex. It's not unreasonable to assume that their sexual expression is as important to their life as human sex is to people like mental patients, social workers and security therapy aides.
Humans have the power to control the sexual expression of less evolved life forms, and we frequently do so just for our peculiar advantage, or if their sexual expression happens to become offensive or inconvenient to us. My dogs are neutered, and my new Ginkgo tree has been genetically engineered to not produce the fruit that would rot and smell bad in October. But why would a fundamental expression of life become offensive or inconvenient? The fact that it clearly does implies some some very basic misunderstanding or disagreement with life itself.
We all want to be as fully alive as we can be. This is the whole impetus of evolution. Human beings developed language, advanced social organization and culture; and we have learned (or at least continuously attempt) to master matter, energy, space, and time itself, in the pursuit of being more alive. That is our game.
But something... maybe about the strategy we are on to win this game, or maybe about the rules, or maybe about an opponent... is mistaken. The facts of sex and our confusions about sex prove this, and urge us to think more carefully.
Why exactly is sex with institutionalized mental patients wrong?
We have so many rules and explanations, and justifications and arguments and theories, which in the end just do not solve the problem: there must be sex but there can't be sex. The problem is nowhere so obvious as at Elgin Mental Health Center and the other nuthouses operated by the Illinois Department of Human Services.
Supposedly EMHC is, "A hospital dedicated by the State of Illinois to the welfare of its people for their relief and restoration, a place of hope for the healing of mind, body and spirit, where many find health and happiness again." That's what it says on the handsome bronze plaque on the wall, right?
Well, certainly sex is part of anyone's version of health and happiness. Why must it be so severely regulated? Why is it banned between patients and staff? Why is it dangerous?
There are people who need to heal mind, body and spirit, and who need to find health and happiness again. In the hospital those people are not supposed to be allowed real sex, and the rules about that are supposed to be helpful to them. There's a whole lot of disagreement though! Most of it is hidden. So what's this complicated story all about?
We create institutions, organizations, social and cultural structures... as evolutionary strategies. Psychiatry, or the medicalized "healing" of human problems in thinking, emotion and behavior, is one such structure or strategy. No strategy is ever perfect by the way, that would make the game be too easy and boring, or it would just be over too quickly. The main point with a strategy is to continuously improve it until the current game is won and a new game becomes available.
All the rules about sex between staff and patients are part of the strategy of medical psychiatry. Other parts of that strategy include the conceptual location of human problems with thinking, emotion and behavior exclusively in the brain and the apotheosis of the brain itself, the use of drugs and other somatic tactics (ECT, etc.), the subordination of other specialized knowledge (psychology, social work, religion) to psychiatry; the prioritization of public funds for what we call "mental health," the shaming of anyone who might be called "anti-psychiatry," and the establishment of legal and financial advantages for pharmaceutical companies and medical enterprises. It's a very big socio-cultural machine, and everybody is supposed to be competent to use it and responsible for getting it repaired when a need arises.
But our civilization has forgotten that this is all a strategy and a machine to be used in the game of life. People believe it's just true. That's why sex is such a big problem: it points insistently to the fact that we sorely need to improve our strategy. Sex embarrasses us. Or maybe (more significantly) it shows that we are missing some of the rules to this game, or that we cannot even identify the goalposts and the opponent.
Of course, we have been repeatedly embarrassed by sex throughout human history. (Think Trump and Stormy Daniels, Mata Hari, Giacomo Casanova, Caesar and Cleopatra, Helen of Troy, and Eve!)
In the more specific history of psychiatry, practitioners were frequently embarrassed. Freud's psychoanalysis was originally billed as science, but it was never popular and available except for repressed rich people who wanted salacious stories. By the 1970s, psychiatry had to renounce libido in favor of neurochemistry to remain a medical specialty that paid well. In the 1980s and 90s, they had to renounce an overwrought minority of their own guys who were pushing a weird theory of multiple personalities caused by satanic, ritualistic sex perpetrated against children by international cannibalistic conspirators supposedly lurking in everyone's neighborhood. (Think Bennet Braun, M.D., and Rush Presbyterian St. Lukes!)
Now they have to disavow state employees proven to have seduced and sexually abused the mentally ill people at their mercy, or other employees proven to have enabled the seduction and abuse. These employees are all supposed to be above suspicion, so they are much more of an embarrassment as professionals who have supposedly dedicated their respective careers to working in mental health facilities, and would never jeopardize their own careers and morals.
It turns out that it's much harder to control the sexuality of human beings than that of house pets or trees. And if we try it's dehumanizing, especially when we fail, which is almost always. We have to pretend that there is no sex between staff and patients at EMHC, or that it's vanishingly rare. Otherwise, this strategy that we call psychiatry has to be seriously questioned.
Psychiatry would be revealed as a fundamental misunderstanding or disagreement with life itself: a bad strategy for the game. We don't want to know that, we have too much invested.
It would be too much work to improve or abandon the strategy.
Saturday, May 25, 2024
Don't harass the working man!
My friend Julio spent many years in Illinois' so-called "forensic mental health" system. He killed somebody and then convinced a judge to send him to a so-called "hospital" instead of prison. So be it. A couple years ago, we managed to get him a conditional release, and now he's living in the community, working every day, not taking any drugs. So far, he's a success story for whoever wants it.
The EMHC "treatment" team gets to imagine that they cured him of the mental illness that caused him to kill somebody (no mean trick). The court that committed him and then released him gets to say it had an accurate sense of justice for not just locking him up for life. I get to say I was right for advocating for his release even though he refused to buy into the required psychiatric state religion. His kids get to have a dad again after a long time. Our capitalist society gets one more taxpayer back on the rolls. Julio is an all-round, pretty good boy.
But he needs to be finally discharged. The plantation system keeps trying, as it always will, to reel him back down to their fields to pick their cotton. He's not much better than a fugitive slave as long as there are conditions on his freedom. He has to live where somebody tells him to live, he has to show up for "meetings" that are part of somebody else's program, and the people running the "meetings" don't care if he thinks he's working a paying job in the real world, because they figure they still own him.
"You had work until 9:00, Julio? So what? I told you to come to the 8:00 meeting!" This was the ignorant harangue from a very young, self-important, new employee named Mario at the group home recently. It actually became an assault and battery, when Julio's chest was aggressively poked by Mario's hard finger, and Mario's angry voice was raised, for several other staff to witness. There could be a legitimate criminal charge or civil claim, which those who were heard laughing about the incident later may know. (Did they laugh because they thought Mario was an idiot for losing it and putting himself in potential trouble; or were they just making fun of the poor submissive slave?)
The 8:00 "meeting" that Mario was so strict and self-important about may have been group counseling, or a substance abuse session, which in theory is mandated by the conditions of Julio's release from EMHC. But anybody with decent intent and a modicum of sense knows that a real, honest job is more therapeutic than all the mental health nonsense any bunch of middling, would-be "slave-overseers-cum-mental-health-professionals" can throw around at night when everybody is tired and short tempered.
Julio is well into middle age. He did his years of time. He learned how to be tolerant and non-aggressive even when idiots like Mario are being idiots. He takes no psych "medications" that the taxpayers of Illinois have to pay for. Nobody notices any "mental illness" in him. He's a productive citizen, a working man. Give him credit for that.
C'mom guys, don't harass him! He's the kind of "mental patient" we all want, the kind we can brag about to legitimize expensive salaries and cumbersome bureaucracies.
And he's very rare, in fact maybe a fable.
Wednesday, May 22, 2024
What the doctor ordered
Sunday, May 19, 2024
Final thoughts from APAAM 2024
Paul Appelbaum made an additional important point near the end of his session on psychedelics on May 5, 2024, in New York City. He said that the experience with Ketamine over the past few years as it became widely used to treat depression, was "not encouraging."
Ketamine for depression is virtually unregulated because the drug has been a legal anesthetic since the 1970s, and doctors can prescribe it off-label as they like, without any standards of practice to guide them. New Ketamine infusion clinics open almost every day all over the country; some of those clinics employ real doctors and some don't, but neither the FDA nor anyone else actively monitors what they do. Ketamine pills are easily ordered over the internet (like Viagra or generic ED drugs) after a "virtual medical consultation from your couch" or a simple on-line survey. The Ketamine pills can be delivered by "free and discreet shipping," once prescribed.
Ironically, the only form of this drug which is actually approved for treatment resistant depression, Janssen's esketamine nasal spray Spravato, is strictly regulated to require a minimal amount of counseling or observation along with the administration of the drug. This counseling or observation makes the treatment much more expensive for the added safety. That expense incentivizes the on-line prescription business, and nobody knows who is doing what with this drug.
Appelbaum suggested that if and when LSD, psilocybin, MDMA and other psychedelics are approved for research or treatment of mental disorders, requiring them to be removed from the FDA's Schedule 1 (designating drugs that have no approved medical use), they will rapidly spread out of control the same way Ketamine did. Juxtaposed against the more banal, even jocular attitudes of the presenters in Stephen Ross' session the previous day (which seemed to be that psychedelics are just medicines to be "studied" for endless collection of crunchable statistics and massive amounts of mostly unevaluated "scientific" data), Appelbaum's warnings were even more stark.
A guy sitting next to me laughed out loud when I leaned over and whispered to him, "Hey, wtf... just prescribe shrooms, man!" as a sarcastic response to some presenter's long-winded worry over the complexities of psychedelic assisted therapy and informed consent.
____________________
It really was altogether strange to me that Drs. Brody, Wilkins, Ford and Lake would have been perfectly happy to never mention that staff are just as likely to be the perpetrators of sexual abuse of patients as other patients are. I have to speculate about this glaringly illogical absence of mention, in the session I attended Sunday morning.
The first thing that occurs to me is an oft repeated, supposedly humorous truism: in any psychiatric hospital it can be quite difficult for outsiders to distinguish the patients from the staff, because they are all totally nuts. It turns out they're all about equally perverted, too. The only difference that applies to sexuality is, patients in a secure setting can be controlled, whereas staff must be predicted.
But just as important as the universality of sexual aberration is the last century's history of psychiatry. As I read it, at the beginning of that time, curing mental diseases had been an extremely unsuccessful medical project. Then Freud came along to make everybody think that great hope lay in long, open and honest talk about sex, leading perhaps to development of standard, rational manners on the subject. That didn't work either, and it was definitely never scalable for big profits. After a few decades, psychiatry gravitated back to medicine (drugs).
Part of the historical sequence brought professional embarrassment to an entire generation of would-be doctors, over the quaintly salacious, often fantasy-based details featured in most psychoanalytic therapy sessions. Headshrinkers looked a lot like perverts. To be accepted as real medical experts on the brain (or mind), psychiatrists just had to stop talking about sex.
This severe, still oddly informal and un-admitted proscription is now reflected in byzantine regulations, requirements and policies for reporting every slightest suspicion institutional staff might ever entertain, of possible patient abuse. In Illinois, state employees are required to refresh their training for this every two years, and they all know they must report anything suspicious within four hours.
But guess what, nobody follows the rules. When it comes to sex, nobody wants to know what anyone else is thinking or perhaps doing, because they don't want anyone to wonder what they are thinking or what they might do, themselves. Nobody can safely accuse the person in the office next door, because then they might be asked to leave their own office door open.
To top it off, state-employed "mental health professionals" all have to hide the fact that they have no slightest clue how to really do what the public pays them for: medical cures for emotional, cognitive and behavioral difficulties. They look over their shoulders every day, anxiously wondering, "Who might know that I am incompetent?"
It's a perfect recipe for a slave plantation or mafia culture.
The people who attended the general session on sexual violence Sunday morning in New York certainly had no willingness to confront my honest questions directly on point. Dr. Brody offered only a weak justification for the omission of any perspective or acknowledgement that staff do sexually abuse patients. There were forty or fifty people there, and my impression was that they were all institutional mental health staff. Everyone remained "cheerfully professional," hoping perhaps that they could remain immune to any accusation.
___________________
The connection between psychiatric "treatments" with psychedelic drugs and sexual abuse of patients lies in the fact that substances like psilocybin, LSD, and MDMA are all about no control. No control of thinking, no control of emotion, no control of behavior, no control of supply and demand, no control of the body, no control of therapy, no control of sexuality, no control of law. This is the precise opposite of science or reason.
The essential instinct of psychiatry is not scientific, it's religious. Psychiatrists are selling salvation with much the same pitch as Jim Jones or Charles Manson. They want to play God, or Satan, and their only affinity for science is as a means to power. With psychedelic drugs they would dissolve the personalities of their patients, and wantonly insert their own personalities, which they insist are much better.
They have always failed in that, and they will continue to fail.